Too-Specific Top 10 – WUBRG! – EDHREC


(Esika, God of the Tree | Art by Johannes Voss)

Welcome to Too-Specific Top 10, the place if there isn’t a class to rank our pet card on the high of, we’ll simply make one up! (Did that Cromat is the one five-color creature with greater than two activated talents?)

When I first acquired into Magic, rares had been the very best rarity in a booster pack (and we solely had one sort of booster pack). Mythics have been launched since then, together with alternate arts and foils of stated mythics, typically solely out there in particular merchandise which might solely be bought in sure areas, if you happen to’re fortunate sufficient to get in by the top of particular time allotments. Perhaps nonetheless the rarest factor of all in Magic: The Gathering, nonetheless, is five-color playing cards.

In reality, previous to the 12 months 2000, the one non-silver-bordered five-color card was the ever-elusive and ever-expensive Sliver Queen. Since then, they’ve gotten fairly a bit extra widespread, alongside the next timeline:

2000: Coalition Victory

2001: Atogatog, Cromat, and Last Stand

2002: None

2003: Karona, False God and Sliver Overlord

2004: Who // What // When // Where // Why

2005: Genju of the Realm

2006: Scion of the Ur-Dragon and Transguild Courier

2007: Horde of Notions and Sliver Legion

2008: Reaper King

2009: Child of Alara, Conflux, Fusion Elemental, Maelstrom Archangel, Maelstrom Nexus, and Progenitus

2010-2013: None

2014: Chromanticore and Sliver Hivelord

2015-2016: None

2017: O-Kagachi, Vengeful Kami, The Ur-Dragon, and Urza, Academy Headmaster

2018: None

2019: Niv-Mizzet Reborn, Sphinx of the Guildpact, and The First Sliver

2020: Sanctum of All

As you possibly can see, it’s not a big checklist. But provided that that is Too-Specific Top 10, why don’t we whittle it down a bit extra?

Top 10 WUBRG Cards

Criteria: Cards with a mana price consisting completely of precisely one mana of every coloration. As is custom, all outcomes are ordered by EDHREC rating.

While there are 30 totally different playing cards that qualify as “five-color”, I’ve at all times personally had a penchant for the best of these very difficult playing cards. So somewhat than standing on Transguild Couriers and the banned Coalition Victory, why not go for the true WUBRGs?

10. Sanctum of All

(1,263 Inclusions, 3% of 36,897 Decks)

Only printed not too long ago in Magic 2021, Sanctum of All is nonetheless a shout-out to an ancient cycle of Shrines from Kamigawa that was additionally printed alongside a second cycle of the identical. It’s good for greater than only a little bit of nostalgia, although. Sanctum of All can search up a Shrine each maintenance, after which get you further triggers for every of them when you begin hitting a important mass. Indeed, most individuals’s one lament for this purpose-printed Shrine Tribal card is that it will probably’t be your commander itself.

9. Maelstrom Archangel

(1,358 Inclusions, 4% of 36,897 Decks)

While Maelstrom Archangel has been just about outdone nowadays by the likes of Jodah, Archmage Eternal, in decks that care about attacking, a number of assault steps, or double strike, it will probably nonetheless put in various work. After all, 5 mana for a 5/5 flier that allows you to solid spells at no cost each time it will get by way of? How might that ever be unhealthy?

8. Sliver Queen

(Helms 249 Decks, Rank #421; 1,569 Inclusions, 4% of 36,897 Decks)

Sliver Queen is the unique Sliver commander, although it’s not some of the well-liked choices for the tribe. However, personally, it’s nonetheless the one which makes me pay probably the most consideration if I see it throughout the desk within the command zone. Sure, Sliver Hivelord, Sliver Legion, and The First Sliver are probably the most highly effective on the face of issues, however Sliver Queen simply screams infinite combos popping out of nowhere.

7. Sliver Legion

(Helms 64 Decks, Rank #727; 1,869 Inclusions, 5% of 36,897 Decks)

Speaking of Sliver Legion, have you ever ever needed to take care of a Craterhoof Behemoth within the command zone? All proper, it’s not that unhealthy. In reality, it’s often worse, given {that a} Sliver participant laying this down right into a full board will typically have haste, trample, shroud, flying, and double strike to go together with the +7/+7 all the pieces is getting.

6. Maelstrom Nexus

(2,509 Inclusions, 7% of 36,897 Decks)

If you’ve by no means seen this card earlier than, get able to be seeing much more of it as soon as all of us get again to our in-person tables. Maelstrom Nexus offers your first spell every flip Cascade, and it does stack if the spell already had Cascade, making the cavalcade of Cascade spells from Commander Legends that rather more value-ridden. What you really want to bear in mind, nonetheless, is that instants can be utilized with this on each participant’s flip, permitting for 4 Cascades per rounding of the desk, successfully. Is {that a} bit far-fetched? Perhaps, however then once more there are whole courses of gamers who dwell for precisely that sort of factor.

5. Sliver Overlord

(Helms 1,537 Decks, Rank #76; 1,223 Inclusions, 3% of 36,897 Decks)

Still the preferred Sliver commander, Sliver Overlord each helps you to seek for particular Slivers and achieve management of any others on the board which will have been stolen or not belonged to you within the first place. I additionally like that it has a number of arms as what was alleged to be a bizarre Sliver flex, solely now there are totally different planes of Slivers that begin with two arms anyhow, so….

4. Niv-Mizzet Reborn

(Helms 1,659 Decks, Rank #65; 1,144 Inclusions, 3% of 36,897 Decks)

Niv-Mizzet Reborn appears like the primary casualty of the flood of playing cards we’ve seen during the last couple years. I say that as a result of I bear in mind when he was first spoiled and the way excited folks had been, but the one time I’ve even seen him performed is in my Cycling version of the deck, which I performed all of 4 video games with earlier than Golos, Tireless Pilgrim got here out. Now, that’s clearly taking my private anecdote to a bigger degree, however actually, if Niv-Mizzet Reborn had been another character, I doubt any of us would even bear in mind this card. Not that it’s not good, thoughts you. It will just about at all times draw you a brand new hand anytime you play it in a deck devoted to the two-color technique, and that’s a singular sufficient technique that individuals wish to construct round it. There are even aggressive builds that can put it to use. However, given the firehose of playing cards that got here out alongside and after it, Niv-Mizzet nonetheless appears somewhat forgettable regardless of that includes a beloved character and a singular potential. Exactly like Obeka, Brute Chronologist, Yurlok of Scorch Thrash, Ghen, Arcanum Weaver, Averna, the Chaos Bloom, and Jared Carthalion, True Heir will most likely really feel by this time subsequent 12 months.

In reality, if you happen to didn’t must search for what not less than a type of virtually brand-new tri-color Commander Legends legends did, then I might be amazed. If you do know what all of them do, then go forward, end the cycle within the feedback from reminiscence. Bet you possibly can’t!

3. Sliver Hivelord

(Helms 447 Decks, Rank #278; 2,479 Inclusions, 7% of 36,897 Decks)

Slivers have at all times felt a bit invincible as soon as they get rolling, however that on no account signifies that when Sliver Hivelord makes it official that it isn’t terrifying. Sure, Crystalline Sliver is likely to be higher beneath a whole lot of circumstances on the larger energy ranges, however there’s one thing to be stated for turning each Wrath of God into an instantaneous alpha strike.

2. The First Sliver

(Helms 1,341 Decks, Rank #93; 1,665 Inclusions, 5% of 36,897 Decks)

If you’re much less involved in successful and extra within the journey, nonetheless, may I curiosity you in The First Sliver? Ironically, this ultra-value-based commander that you could see spinning its wheels at a desk close to you was really a Competitive EDH staple for a time, helming Food Chain decks the world over. Most instances nowadays you’re extra prone to simply see a Timmy or Tammy flipping playing cards over with it, nonetheless. I, for one, am right here for that, as The First Sliver is perhaps the one enjoyable model of a Sliver deck left to the plenty. Remember, youngsters, variance is the spice of life. If you’re bored of your decks successful the very same means each sport, perhaps don’t play all of the tutors on this planet?

1. Scion of the Ur-Dragon

(Helms 744 Decks, Rank #192; 2,264 Inclusions, 6% of 36,897 Decks)

Speaking of tutoring for a similar three win circumstances, Scion of the Ur-Dragon!

Okay, I’ll attempt to preserve my #PlayLessTutors mantra in examine for a minute; even I can inform that it’s getting tiresome.

Honestly although, regardless of my inherent biases, I actually like Scion. It requires an epic quantity of mana or an additional flip to essentially get going, and even then often has a bunch of loopy convoluted schemes to truly get to the win. Failing that, it will probably typically simply lead to a loopy final flip the place 18 Dragons rise from the grave and swing out, and who isn’t a fan of that?

Honorable Mentions

Cutting our unique checklist from 30 right down to 19 acquired us a extra obscure checklist, which I’m at all times a fan of. However, it additionally lets us simply go proper on itemizing proper right down to the model new WUBRG instance we acquired out of Kaldheim, which is likely to be some of the thrilling new five-color playing cards we’ve gotten in years.

11. Child of Alara
12. Horde of Notions
13. Chromanticore
14. Cromat
15. Genju of the Realm
16. Fusion Elemental
17. Atogatog
18. Last Stand
19. The Prismatic Bridge

Seriously, although, it saddens me to see Last Stand not getting any love. Makes me glad I haven’t lower the Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth package deal from my five-color Cycling, actually.

Nuts and Bolts

There at all times appears to be a little bit of curiosity in how these lists are made (this looks like a great time to emphasize as soon as once more that they’re primarily based on EDHREC rating, NOT my private opinion), and individuals are typically shocked that I’m not utilizing any particular knowledge or .json from EDHREC, however somewhat simply muddling my means by way of with some Scryfall knowledge! For your enjoyment/analysis, here is this week’s Scryfall search.

What Do You Think?

And lastly, what’s your favourite WUBRG card? Do you favor the strict “one mana of each type” mana price, or are the extra distinctive or costly variations high quality in your guide?

Let us know within the feedback, and we’ll see you on the spherical desk painted like R&D‘s well-known coloration wheel! (Man I hope that exists someplace.)

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here