The Queen is Dead – EDHREC


(Liliana, Death’s Majesty | Art by Chris Rallis)


Okay, I can’t shout for the entire article. I’m gonna blow out my keyboard utilizing it that arduous. Let’s channel the spirit of the vikings in much less shouty methods, like uh, the musical side! We can all be very cheery and bouncing throughout this text. That’s a lot better.

40: Tamiyo, Collector of Tales: 5,505 Decks

It’s fairly simple to take a look at the +1 and the static on Tamiyo, Collector of Tales and conclude she’s not likely made for Commander. Heck, I did after I first noticed it, however that’s as a result of I used to be wanting on the +1 as a means to attract playing cards. It will clearly by no means do this in Commander. You know what that +1 actually says? Mill 4. Ignore some other phrases on that capability, that’s all you want. I’ve resorted to Wood Sage earlier than as a result of repeatable mill fills your graveyard up all day lengthy!

See, the factor about Tamiyo is that she’s secretly a Sultai card, as a result of not solely does Sultai love filling the graveyard, however in addition they love Regrowth. Even at her worst, Tamiyo is a four-mana sorcery Regrowth, which is nonetheless an important card to have while you want that Toxic Deluge again. The incontrovertible fact that Tamiyo may also gasoline her recursion with the +1 offers her numerous worth while you don’t want one thing again instantly.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Just Right: Plus, any future recursion with Tamiyo within the graveyard has some fairly nice returns. Looping Tamiyo with an Eternal Witness is the epitome of spinning your wheels, and I like it.

39: Liliana, Heretical Healer: 5,756 Decks

(598 Decks as a commander, 5,158 decks as a card)

Liliana, Heretical Healer is the one creature ‘walker where her being a creature is an asset. It’s extremely simply to flip Lily, however the reward for doing so isn’t superb by itself. The solely actually thrilling capability is the -X. That will often snag a good creature, but when she solely does it as soon as, that’s most likely worse than even a card like Rise from the Grave. However, because of her creature facet, you’ll be able to simply get her again with stuff like Meren of Clan Nel Toth and do this -X a number of occasions. It’s a soul-crushing loop of demise and resurrection. Hooray!

Over, Under, or Just Right? Just Right: Not a heady historic handmaiden, however a humble heretical healer.

38: Kiora, Behemoth Beckoner: 5,812 Decks

When persons are enjoying playing cards like The Great Henge, and Temur Ascendancy, Kiora, Behemoth Beckoner doesn’t precisely stand out. She supplies some ramp together with her -1, and it’s cute with stuff like Karametra’s Acolyte, however I don’t assume that makes up for the fragility of being a planeswalker. Seven loyalty is a ton, however the truth that she will be able to die is a particular draw back, particularly when in comparison with stuff like Guardian Project, which is all upside. It’s all the time good to run one or two playing cards like Project, however Kiora is by no means going to be one of the best one.

What’s that? Kiora is 50 cents? Like, the proper funds card for any Simic deck, not like most of these different card draw choices?

Excuse me a second. I have to go discover 50 copies of this.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Underplayed: This and Garruk’s Uprising are mainly the one funds Guardian Projects that exist, so even when they aren’t one of the best, they need to be in mainly any stompy deck that may play them

37: Jace, Vryn’s Prodigy: 5,873 Decks

(259 Decks as a commander, 5,614 decks as a card)

I truly actually love Jace, Vryn’s Prodigy. It’s one among my favourite playing cards I’ve by no means owned, however I believe that his Snapcaster Mage capability isn’t nice in EDH. That -2 is the primary motive numerous decks are working him, however why undergo the hassle of doing that when you can simply return the spell with Call to Mind or Mystic Retrieval or Regrowth? Jace is so dang sluggish. Sure, you’ll be able to wait to flip him till you’ve got one thing good to forged, however top-decking Jace is means worse than simply top-decking Call to Mind as a result of you need to wait a full flip cycle earlier than you will get your spell again, or worse, get your Snapcaster plan ruined by a elimination spell. It’s simply far an excessive amount of effort when there’re higher methods to do it

Over, Under, or Just Right? Overplayed: And for those who’re not Snapcastering, there’s mainly nothing else for him to do. His different talents are even worse.

36: Ajani, the Greathearted: 5,892 Decks

So I’ve been teasing the budget Superfriends deck for some time, partly as a result of I’m the kind of particular person that might stroll right into a gold-leaf-wrapped caviar retailer and ask, “So what can I get for $2?” However, I believe funds superfriends appeals to me quite a bit as a result of it was actually not a factor you can do just a few years in the past. Even the most affordable ‘walkers used to run you $5-10, to not point out that the cool ones all people needs to play like Jace, the Mind Sculptor costing upward of $100. No highschool scholar’s bought the funds for a kind of, let me inform you, and I didn’t even contact on the five-color mana base or the white whale of this sequence, Doubling Season. Superfriends was positively the deck for those who wished to actually splurge.

But now, because of War of the Spark’s introducing a ton of low-cost ‘walkers like Ajani, the Greathearted, I believe you’ll be able to completely construct $50 superfriends. Sure, you’ll be able to’t afford a few of the high tier ‘walkers, like Tamiyo, the Moon Sage, however because of WAR, and a bunch of different units, you have a ton of cheap replacements. Lots of the assist playing cards, like Deploy the Gatewatch, are additionally pretty low-cost. Heck, Oath of Teferi is solely $1.50, and that’s one of many scariest playing cards in any superfriends deck. Even Doubling Season, whereas nonetheless being completely distinctive and an “I Win” button for the tribe, has stuff like Evolution Sage or Deepglow Skate that may fill the same function. Sure, it received’t have the flashiest ‘walkers, like Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh, however let’s be actual, most of these ‘walkers weren’t actually nice playing cards in Commander, anyway. I’m at the very least fascinated with making an attempt to construct funds superfriends and I encourage you all to attempt as nicely.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Underplayed: 14-year-old me can be proud.

35: Dack Fayden: 5,946 Decks

Okay, I’ve been fairly imply to the Izzet planeswalkers, however I can’t be impolite to the best thief of the multiverse, Dack Fayden. Everybody was freaking out about Thieving Skydiver as a brand new EDH staple, and even that price one million mana to steal even only a Hedron Archive. Dack Fayden however? It’s the identical quantity of mana to steal a Sol Ring or a Blightsteel Colossus, and when he doesn’t have factor to steal, he may also simply Careful Study each single flip. You by no means draw lifeless with a Dack in play.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Just Right: Like, who cares if Dack dies in a flip or two? His flooring is card. His ceiling is a tremendous card!

34: Vraska, Golgari Queen: 5,955 Decks

If I ever made an inventory of worst loyalty talents on ‘walkers, I believe Vraska, Golgari Queen‘s +1 is perhaps the one non-Planeswalker Deck, non-Tibalt ‘walker on there. Most of the time, you’ll simply tick up and do nothing, and isn’t that an important capability? “+2: do absolutely nothing.” Maybe you’ll have a ineffective mana rock or land to sacrifice to it, however you’re most likely going to want these till late within the sport. Even while you do draw a card off the +2, Vraska’s nonetheless this large sitting duck.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Overplayed: The remainder of the cardboard would wish to actually wow me to beat that, and it actually doesn’t. The minus is simply okay, and whereas I’ll concede that the last word is very humorous, it’s gonna be without end earlier than she will get there. I can’t even actually say she’s good in superfriends. Your return on funding is fairly sluggish.

33: Karn, Scion of Urza: 5,997 Decks

I travel on how good Karn is. I’ve by no means seen it in play, so I can’t actually pull on any earlier expertise right here. The most interesting factor right here is he’s a colorless means to attract playing cards, and we’re nonetheless fairly hungry for that even with stuff like Coercive Portal and The Immortal Sun present. He’s not superb card draw, however you’ll be able to often strike a cope with an opponent to get a key wrath or elimination spell that you just would possibly reveal. That’s additionally not all he does, both. In artifact decks, the Karnstructs might be large creatures that may defend Karn or simply assault for ten.

There’s positively quite a bit to love right here. There’s simply numerous draw back if Karn flips two lands off the +1 after which dies. That’s a reasonably low flooring on Karn. I believe if I have been constructing a deck and owned a Karn, I’d attempt him out anyway as a result of there is a lot to love, however he’s additionally $8. Like, I might purchase Staff of Nin, Mind’s Eye, and a Coke Zero for that value. I don’t know if I can justify giving him a shot.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Overplayed: I’d nonetheless wish to see Karn in play. I believe there’s an opportunity he’s higher than he seems to be

32: Nissa, Voice of Zendikar: 6,053 Decks

I’ve come to the conclusion that Nissa, Voice of Zendikar is some type of hypnotic wizard disguised as a Magic card. People see this card, and I swear they hear this siren name. Oooh, a +1 that makes Plant tokens that work nicely with pump spells. Oooh, a minus that pumps an entire crew. Oooh, she works nicely with Proliferate because it will increase the +1/+1 counters she offers and offers her extra loyalty counters. Woooooooooooooaaaah.

And then one way or the other, in seeing all this cool synergy, they enter right into a catatonic state and are oblivious to what Nissa truly does more often than not, which is both “Make a 0/1 Plant, and then die,” or “Do a Gavony Township after which die.” Being three mana is not a boon for Nissa as a result of the 0/1s are actually horrible at defending her from any protection stronger than a loaf of bread. Most video games I see Nissa, it is very simple for me to kill her, and I’ll say that to individuals, and so they’ll say, “Oh, but when that doesn’t happen, she’ll really go off.” When does that not occur, world? What black magic hath contaminated y’all?!?

Over, Under, or Just Right? Overplayed: I swear, both I’m in video games the place Nissa will get extremely unfortunate, or Wizards has been sneaking some type of catnip into the cardboard.

31: Liliana, Death’s Majesty: 6,078 Decks

Poll time! When’s the final time you’ve seen a Rise from the Grave forged? I anticipate two solutions: by no means, or final week. Rise from the Grave is fairly outclassed by stuff like Reanimate, Stitch Together, Ever After, Extract from Darkness, and so on. There’s positively higher choices, and for those who’re enjoying in a higher-power meta, you’ll most likely by no means see this card.

But additionally, it’s not dangerous. Wizards, for some motive, likes to place this card in precons, so relying on the place I’m enjoying, I’ll see Rise a good bit, and I gotta inform you, I lose to it quite a bit. You can say no matter “strictly better” choice you need, however the reality is video games have a tendency to finish while you forged a five-mana Terastodon, or a five-mana Diluvian Primordial, or a five-mana Craterhoof Behemoth… you get the concept. It kinda doesn’t matter that Rise from the Grave feels so mediocre. It’s a mediocre option to get one of the best creature any deck is enjoying. That kinda needs to be good.

So after I speak about Liliana, Death’s Majesty (See, my rambles have a degree… typically) and say that 95% of the time she’s simply Rise from the Grave restricted to your graveyard, that’s not a foul factor. Sure, when she will get to stay round, she’s a lot better. You can sometimes get to the last word, which is going to be fairly one-sided in the suitable deck, however usually that’s only a bonus. Most of the time, she’s an costly Reanimate that good points you some life, and that’s completely advantageous.

Over, Under, or Just Right? Just Right: Does that rating seek advice from Rise from the Grave or Liliana? Yes.

Staying on Topic? What’s That Mean?

Well, go have fun the Kaldheim previews by studying to play a Talharpa. While you’re doing that, sing about what you concentrate on this batch of ‘walkers. Is Vraska, Golgari Queen higher than I believe? Do you’ve got a funds superfriends deck? Serenade your ideas within the feedback. Until subsequent week.

Joseph began enjoying in Theros Block however determined that one of the best ways to play the sport was to study each single card and hope that might one way or the other make him good at Magic. It hasn’t. He is a university scholar in Santa Fe, New Mexico and likewise enjoys studying and different video games of all sizes and shapes.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here